This page was originally written in Indonesian. This English version was translated automatically using machine translation (AI/Google engine) and may contain contextual inaccuracies. View the original Indonesian version.

Article 160 Is Still There. The Agency to Run It Is Not.

Ilustrasi dua jalur regulasi migas bertemu di satu simpul terkunci, menggambarkan benturan kewenangan RUU Migas dengan Pasal 160 UUPA di perairan Aceh
AIL1 This article has a companion document: a 54-page review of the Oil and Gas Bill, available on request

In 2020 I helped design the business processes of Badan Pengelola Migas Aceh (BPMA), the agency set up to manage oil and gas in Aceh. For months we worked with boxes, lines, and arrows. We set out who does what, where a piece of work begins, and whose decision has to come in before the next step can move. One authority can involve several institutions. Each of them needs a clear role. Without that, a decision can stall even though every party believes it has done its part.

That work changed how I read a statute. I want to know how an article actually gets carried out. Who signs, who approves, and to whom the person doing the work answers. An authority that sounds firm in a law can blur once it is turned into daily work.

That is how I read the Oil and Gas Bill in its 1 April 2026 version. I followed the order of its decisions, starting with the designation and offering of working areas, then the signing of contracts, then approval of field development, and on to supervision and cost audit. The exercise grew into a 54-page review.

In a piece I published on 25 August, I warned that Aceh's authority was at risk of being pushed aside. The risk comes if a new agency is created without firm recognition of BPMA and of Aceh's special status. What I had then was a worry. This piece carries it further by tracing the articles that decide who makes the call.

What I found concerns where Aceh sits in the structure of authority the bill would create.

Infografis lima poin titik benturan RUU Migas 1 April 2026 dengan pengaturan khusus migas Aceh, termasuk dua rezim penerimaan 70 persen dan 30 persen
The five points I set out below, condensed onto one page.

In the version I reviewed, no article expressly repeals Article 160 of the Law on the Governing of Aceh. I also found no sufficient basis for claiming that the drafters set out to harm Aceh. The absence of a repeal, though, does not settle how the article is to be carried out.

A full-text search I ran across the 247-page academic manuscript returned no occurrence of the word Aceh, of BPMA, or of the phrase otonomi khusus, special autonomy. Chapter III of that manuscript lists fifteen related laws, from forestry to the ban on monopolistic practice. The laws that govern the special status of Aceh and Papua are not on the list.

The absence of those words is not enough to establish the drafters' motive. Calling it an oversight is still a guess. What can be asked for now is an explanation of how the drafters accounted for the oil and gas arrangements already in force in Aceh.

Two signatories for one contract

Article 5 paragraph (4) of the bill places the entire conduct of upstream business with the new agency. Article 63 paragraph (3) letter e gives that agency the power to sign cooperation contracts. For the area under Aceh's authority, which Article 1 point 22 of Government Regulation No. 23 of 2015 limits to land and sea out to 12 nautical miles, Articles 37 and 44 of the same regulation make BPMA the party that contracts with the contractor. Article 44 paragraph (2) adds that the signing takes place after it has been agreed with the Governor and approved by the Minister on behalf of the Government.

This is the point where the two sets of rules have to be squared with each other in plain terms.

Government Regulation No. 23 of 2015 carries out a mandate in the Law on the Governing of Aceh. Article 160 provides for joint management of oil and gas by the Government and the Government of Aceh, including the option of appointing or forming a joint implementing body. Paragraph (5) directs that the detail be set by government regulation. Because that is where its legal basis lies, repealing the 2001 Oil and Gas Law does not by itself erase Government Regulation No. 23 of 2015.

The transitional provisions I read in the bill keep the implementing rules of the 2001 Oil and Gas Law in force so long as they have not been replaced and do not conflict with the new law. That wording does not specifically reach Government Regulation No. 23 of 2015, which draws on a different statute.

Nor does any of this automatically strip BPMA of its authority. The problem is that the relationship between BPMA's authority and the new agency's authority has not been settled clearly enough. If the new law hands overlapping functions to another institution, the people doing the work in the field are left to decide for themselves how the two sets of rules are to be read together.

That ambiguity has to be resolved before the implementation stage. The Government of Aceh, BPMA, and contractors need certainty before they sign a contract or file for approval. A dispute over authority will eat up time that should go into doing the work.

Tim LMAN dan BPMA bersama penulis memeriksa jalur pipa dan katup di Point A Wilayah Kerja B, Aceh
Checking assets at Point A, Working Area B, with the LMAN and BPMA teams. Authority written into an article is in the end carried out in places like this. Author's own photograph.

Seventy percent that turns into thirty

The question of regional revenue can slip past unnoticed while attention goes to the creation of the new agency.

In the bill I reviewed, the agency is funded from a percentage of upstream non-tax state revenue. There is also an oil and gas fund drawn from a percentage of net revenue and held in an account in the Minister's name. The size of both is left to be set by government regulation. The regional entitlement, meanwhile, is framed as a share of net proceeds, a term that gets no definition of its own in Article 1.

Where those two funding items sit relative to the calculation of the regional share has to be made explicit. If both reduce the revenue base that gets divided, the region can end up with less even though the percentage of its entitlement has not moved.

The difficulty grows because Aceh's share today does not come from a single figure. There are two revenue regimes separated by the 12-mile line, and inside the first regime there is one more line still.

For the area under Aceh's authority, meaning the land and the sea out to 12 nautical miles, the regional share flows through revenue sharing transfers. Article 181 paragraph (3) of the Law on the Governing of Aceh sets an additional 55 percent for oil and 40 percent for gas. The word additional deserves underlining, because those two figures sit on top of the general revenue share rather than replacing it. The implementing rules state the final result. Article 39 paragraph (4) of Minister of Finance Regulation No. 35 of 2026 sets Aceh's share at 70 percent of non-tax state revenue from oil and 70 percent from gas for every producing region within Aceh, special autonomy increment included. Inside that same area of authority the split turns out not to be uniform. Article 117 of Law No. 1 of 2022 separates the general revenue share at the 4-mile line. The total does not change, still 15.5 percent for oil and 30.5 percent for gas, but the list of recipients shifts. Beyond 4 miles out to 12, the producing province's share rises from 2 percent to 5 percent for oil and from 4 percent to 10 percent for gas, while producing regencies and cities are no longer named separately.

Beyond 12 nautical miles out to 200, the numbers reverse. Article 3 of Government Regulation No. 23 of 2015 limits the Government of Aceh's involvement in that zone to supervising and monitoring production reports. Article 69 divides the revenue 70 percent to the Government and 30 percent to the Government of Aceh.

Look at where the numbers fall. The 4-mile line only rearranges the split inside Aceh. It is the 12-mile line that actually cuts Aceh's share. Within its own area Aceh gets 70 percent. Once a working area moves past 12 miles, that share shrinks to 30 percent. And it is in the farther zone that Aceh's largest prospects lie.

A third idea circulates outside those two regimes. Rifqi Nuril Huda is an expert staffer at the DPR, Indonesia's national legislature. Writing in ANTARA on 19 August 2026, he argued that revenue sharing for producing regions deserves to be strengthened to at least 20 percent for oil and 35 percent for gas. That is the author's personal view, not a formula that has entered the bill. How it would sit against the two regimes above has never been explained by anyone.

A change in the general revenue sharing percentages does not by itself change Aceh's increment. The risk I am raising appears if new rules change the revenue that forms the basis for the split, or widen the deductions taken against it. In that case the amount Aceh receives can move even though the 55 and 40 percent figures stay intact, and even though the 70 percent in the ministerial regulation stays on the page.

The question that has to be answered is simple. Seventy percent of which revenue?

I am not claiming that Aceh's revenue will certainly fall. The amounts and the method of calculation still have to be examined. That is exactly why the drafters have to spell out the revenue components, the deductions allowed, and the order in which the arithmetic runs. Leaving all of it vague moves the argument out of the legislature and onto the desk of whoever executes the budget.

For Aceh, that vagueness carries the weight of history. The General Elucidation of the Law on the Governing of Aceh places the Memorandum of Understanding of 15 August 2005 in the background of how the law came about. Joint management of oil and gas became part of the relationship between the center and Aceh that the law went on to regulate. Changing national oil and gas governance means taking account of institutional arrangements that are already running.

What the DPR can still do

The DPR and the government can still settle this during deliberation of the bill.

Gedung DPR RI di Senayan dilihat dari gedung sebelah dengan latar gedung bertingkat Jakarta
The DPR building in Senayan. The photograph was taken when I attended a meeting with a member of the DPR from an Aceh electoral district to present the concept for normalizing KEK Arun Lhokseumawe. Author's own photograph.

Express recognition of BPMA, clarity on revenue sharing, and a guarantee for existing contracts, which I asked for back in August, remain the core demands. This review ties each of the three to the articles that need clarifying. Precedents for how to word them already exist, both for preserving the special arrangements and for securing contract continuity.

The leadership of the DPR needs to formally request consultation and advice from DPRA, the Aceh legislature. Article 8 paragraph (2) of the Law on the Governing of Aceh provides that mechanism for any plan to make a law that bears directly on the Governing of Aceh. My proposal is that this happens before deliberation of the Daftar Inventarisasi Masalah, the list of proposed amendments, is finished, while input can still change the wording.

The commission handling the bill also needs to schedule a public hearing with the Government of Aceh, DPRA, and BPMA. They should have room to explain how joint management actually works, which decisions involve Aceh, and which parts risk colliding with the new agency's authority.

What comes out of that consultation has to land in the articles themselves. A statement that the special status of Aceh is respected needs to come with clarity about which institution carries it out and how the authorities relate to each other. Protection of revenue entitlements also has to cover the basis of calculation. Wording that respects in general terms will leave the same problem waiting once contracts and budgets start being worked on.

The contract guarantee has to be firm as well. Article 90 of Government Regulation No. 23 of 2015 once governed the transfer of contract rights and obligations from SKK Migas to BPMA while keeping existing contracts valid until their terms expired. That experience can serve as a reference for drafting transitional provisions that preserve contract continuity and make clear who exercises authority over them. One thing cannot be skipped here. Article 90 itself rests on SKK Migas, the very institution this bill would dissolve, so what gets borrowed is the pattern of the wording, not its content.

For the relationship with the special status laws, Article 187 letter f of Law No. 1 of 2022 offers a precedent. That article expressly preserves the revenue sharing provisions in the special status laws for Aceh and Papua. Its limit has to be read carefully. Those provisions stay in force only so long as Law No. 1 of 2022 itself does not provide otherwise, not the special status laws. The protection it gives is conditional, not permanent. The DPR wrote that wording itself, and it shows that a direct reference to the special status laws is possible without dismantling the national architecture. For the Oil and Gas Bill, the scope of protection needs to be drafted to fit the problems of authority and revenue actually at hand.

Supporting document

The 54-page review I put together has seven parts, including a before-and-after comparison of the rules and a matrix of thirteen points of potential conflict. I set out how the decision chain changes and examine the basis on which revenue is calculated. Draft wording is also ready as material for the Daftar Inventarisasi Masalah and for deliberation.

I share that document on a limited basis because several of its formulations are being argued for in the deliberation process. I need to know the purpose it will be used for. Anyone who needs it for work connected to the Oil and Gas Bill can request it through the form below, and I review each request one by one.

Aceh's Oil and Gas at the Senayan Crossroads

A 54-page review of the Oil and Gas Bill, 1 April 2026 version: a matrix of thirteen points of potential conflict, a before-and-after comparison of the rules, and draft wording ready for deliberation of the Daftar Inventarisasi Masalah. Classified Dokumen Sangat Terbatas, highly restricted, and I review each request one by one.

Request the document

Read the review summary

In 2020, our work demanded that every box in the business process have someone to run it and every decision someone answerable for it. The same demand applies to this bill. Before passing it, the DPR and the government have to make sure Aceh's authority can be exercised without waiting for a dispute to explain what it means.

Sources and References

  • Draf Rancangan Undang-Undang Minyak dan Gas Bumi, 1 April 2026 version (104 articles). A working document for deliberation, read directly. Every reference in this piece to Article 5, Article 63, and the transitional provisions comes from that text. Not available as a public document on the date this piece was published.
  • Naskah Akademik RUU Minyak dan Gas Bumi (247 pages). Read directly, with a full-text search. Chapter III lists fifteen related laws. Not available as a public document on the date this piece was published.
  • Undang-Undang Nomor 11 Tahun 2006 tentang Pemerintahan Aceh. The basis for Article 8 paragraph (2), Article 160, Article 181 paragraph (3), and the General Elucidation quoted above. Link.
  • Peraturan Pemerintah Nomor 23 Tahun 2015 tentang Pengelolaan Bersama Sumber Daya Alam Minyak dan Gas Bumi di Aceh. The basis for Article 1 point 22 on the 0 to 12 nautical mile limit of the area of authority, Article 3 on involvement in the 12 to 200 mile zone being limited, Articles 37 and 44 on BPMA as the contracting party, Article 69 on the 70 to 30 revenue split, and Article 90 on contract transfer and continuity. Link.
  • Peraturan Menteri Keuangan Nomor 35 Tahun 2026 tentang Pengelolaan Dana Bagi Hasil dan Dana Alokasi Umum. The basis for Article 39 paragraph (4), page 34, which sets Aceh's share at 70 percent of non-tax state revenue from oil and gas for every producing region within Aceh, special autonomy increment included. Issued 20 May 2026, in force 25 May 2026, repealing PMK Nomor 67 Tahun 2024. Link.
  • Undang-Undang Nomor 1 Tahun 2022 tentang Hubungan Keuangan antara Pemerintah Pusat dan Pemerintahan Daerah. The basis for Article 117, which splits the general oil and gas revenue share at the 4-mile line without changing the total, and for Article 187 letter f, which serves as the precedent for protective wording. Link.
  • Rifqi Nuril Huda, Mencari Jalan Baru Regulasi Migas Indonesia, ANTARA, 19 August 2026. The source of the proposal for revenue sharing of at least 20 percent for oil and 35 percent for gas for producing regions. The author is an expert staffer at the DPR, and the piece is a personal opinion. Link.
  • Ali Mulyagusdin, Two Trains, One Track? The Oil and Gas Bill and BPMA's Fate, 25 August 2026. The predecessor piece, which sets out the chronology of deliberation in the DPR and Aceh's three demands. Link.

Leave a Reply

See Also

Memuat artikel terkait…